Difference between revisions of "Europe Sustainability Tour 2012"

From Green Garage Detroit
Jump to: navigation, search
(Kalundborg Symbiosis Center)
(Other Symbiosis Resources)
 
(10 intermediate revisions by the same user not shown)
Line 6: Line 6:
 
Came from our  3 hour meeting with Mette Skovbjerg, Project Manager and Berndt Jespersen on Tuesday - April 10, 2012.
 
Came from our  3 hour meeting with Mette Skovbjerg, Project Manager and Berndt Jespersen on Tuesday - April 10, 2012.
  
* There is a company in Sweden that is selling greenhouses called Plantagon.  Very advanced approach.  Hans Hassle, the owner, is very advanced in his thinking. 
+
===== Basic Concepts =====
** They also have a philosophy for [http://plantagon.com/urban-agriculture/industrial-symbiosis Industrial Symbiosis for urban agriculture].
+
----
 +
* '''How it works'''
 +
** Waste of one company = Raw material for the next
 +
** Unit Transferred = Waste Fraction
 +
** Please note the "mindset is free!"
  
* The UK has formed the NISP - National Industrial Symbiosis Program (?)
+
* '''Agreements''': ...each interconnect --- symbiotic relationship has:
** They are trying to help get industrial symbiosis' formed....lots on their website
+
** They have a website where you can post your waste you want to "sell"
+
** They have a facilitation approach to find waste matches
+
 
+
* Please note the "mindset is free!"
+
 
+
* by 2010 100% of Denmark's energy is to be renewable.
+
 
+
* One windmill = 400 mWatts
+
** People don't like the way they look
+
** Pension funds are funding the projects
+
** One of Bern's neighbors funded one.
+
** How about Catalaunch and wind
+
** Building on land is 1 fraction of cost of building at sea
+
 
+
* Waste of one company = Raw material for the next
+
 
+
* Each interconnect --- symbiotic relationship has:
+
 
** an arms length commercial agreement
 
** an arms length commercial agreement
 
*** Agreements are typically 10 - 15 years
 
*** Agreements are typically 10 - 15 years
Line 33: Line 19:
 
** grew organically...no master plan, not a project, not an organization...it's a mindset  
 
** grew organically...no master plan, not a project, not an organization...it's a mindset  
 
*** seems to have been started by bthe engineers working together
 
*** seems to have been started by bthe engineers working together
 +
** have a "market" basis e.g. use 30 day energy rates for heat transfer
  
* Examples -
+
* '''Principles'''
** Fish farming  ... uses 9C water from the power plant
+
 
+
* Symbiosis evolution
+
** 1.0 pure economics
+
** 2.0 Green...clean future together
+
*** the power plant needs to be green by demand of the pharmacutical company
+
*** "Can we solve this future better together?"  Can get more by working together
+
 
+
*  Unit Transferred = Waste Fraction
+
 
+
* Principles
+
 
** 1) Members that fit together can (need) to be different  
 
** 1) Members that fit together can (need) to be different  
 
*** more difficult to combine waste streams of similar companies
 
*** more difficult to combine waste streams of similar companies
*** cluster theories of economics
 
*** Yale has a great [http://cie.research.yale.edu/ Center for Industrial Ecology]; key Professor is  [http://environment.yale.edu/profile/chertow Marian Chertow].
 
 
** 2) Focus on continuous waste streams   
 
** 2) Focus on continuous waste streams   
 
*** Some are combining waste streams for several "suppliers" to meet the need
 
*** Some are combining waste streams for several "suppliers" to meet the need
Line 55: Line 29:
 
*** Payback timeframes have moved from 3-5yrs to 1-2 yrs
 
*** Payback timeframes have moved from 3-5yrs to 1-2 yrs
 
** 4) Physical location needs to be close by
 
** 4) Physical location needs to be close by
** 5) Mental distance needs to be short
+
** 5) Mental distance between partners needs to be short
 +
 
 +
* '''Value Pyramid''' (using $/lb)...make the highest use of the waste
 +
** 1) Medicine / Beauty ($/lb)
 +
** 2) Nutrient
 +
** 3) Animal Food
 +
** 4) Energy
 +
** unit prices go up dramatically
 +
** first... use output at highest value
 +
 
 +
* '''Symbiosis evolution'''
 +
** 1.0 pure economics
 +
** 2.0 Green...clean future together
 +
*** the power plant needs to be green by demand of the pharmacutical company
 +
*** "Can we solve this future better together?"  Can get more by working together
 +
 
 +
<br style="clear:both;"/>
 +
 
 +
===== Symbionic Examples =====
 +
----
 +
 
 +
* Fish farming  ... uses 9C water from the power plant
  
 
* Pyroneer = gasifier  
 
* Pyroneer = gasifier  
  
* Algae innovators ecoduna
+
* Gypno - gypsum company near a power plant
** Out of Austria
+
 
** Have production in Germany with a Swedish power company Vattenfall
+
<br style="clear:both;"/>
 +
 
 +
===== Other Symbiosis Resources =====
 +
----
 +
* '''[http://www.symbiocity.org/ SymbioCity]''' - Sweden's national vision and support for sustainable cities based on industrial symbiosis.     
 +
* '''Plantagon'''
 +
** There is a company in Sweden that is selling greenhouses called Plantagon. 
 +
** Very advanced approach. 
 +
** Hans Hassle, the owner, is very advanced in his thinking. 
 +
** They also have a philosophy for [http://plantagon.com/urban-agriculture/industrial-symbiosis Industrial Symbiosis for urban agriculture].
 +
* '''NISP - National Industrial Symbiosis Program''' in the UK
 +
** They are trying to help get industrial symbiosis' formed....lots on their website
 +
** They have a website where you can post your waste you want to "sell"
 +
** They have a facilitation approach to find waste matches
 +
* '''Yale University''' [http://cie.research.yale.edu/ Center for Industrial Ecology];
 +
** Key Professor is  [http://environment.yale.edu/profile/chertow Marian Chertow]. [http://environment.yale.edu/profile/chertow/research
 +
*** Summary of Dr. Chertow's research]...actually a very good summary of the whole area of Industrial Symbiosis.
 +
 
 +
<br style="clear:both;"/>
 +
 
 +
===== Other Sustainability Ideas =====
 +
----
 +
* '''Wind Turbines''' ... Berndt's info
 +
** One windmill = 400 mWatts
 +
** People don't like the way they look
 +
** Pension funds are funding the projects
 +
** One of Bern's neighbors funded one.
 +
** How about Catalaunch and wind
 +
** Building on land is 1 fraction of cost of building at sea
 +
** by 2010 100% of Denmark's energy is to be renewable!
  
* Gypno - gypsum company near a power plant
+
* '''Algae''' innovators [http://www.ecoduna.com/pages/en/mainsite/home.php ecoduna]
 +
** Out of Austria
 +
** Have production in Germany with a power company Vattenfall...project can be read about [http://www.ecoduna.com/pages/en/mainsite/ecoduna-vattenfall.php here].
  
* Solum  
+
* '''Solum'''
 
** Anaerobic Digestion company from Denmark
 
** Anaerobic Digestion company from Denmark
 
** Aikan technology
 
** Aikan technology
Line 72: Line 98:
 
** Very low tech...but very innovative in the design
 
** Very low tech...but very innovative in the design
  
* Heat storage in vertical tanks
+
* '''Heat storage in vertical tanks'''
 
** 125C at top and 50C at the bottom (presurized)
 
** 125C at top and 50C at the bottom (presurized)
 
** Use stratification to help.
 
** Use stratification to help.
 
** put input heat in the top...put cold in the bottom
 
** put input heat in the top...put cold in the bottom
 
** could mix if you need some temp in between
 
** could mix if you need some temp in between
** uses large collendar like filters at the top and bottom to take the input but prevent the mixing  
+
** uses large collendar like filters at the top and bottom to take the input but prevent the mixing
 
+
* Value Pyramid (using $/lb)
+
** 1) Medicine / Beauty ($/lb)
+
** 2) Nutrient
+
** 3) Animal Food
+
** 4) Energy
+
** unit prices go up dramatically
+
** first... use output at highest value
+
 
+
 
+
* Symbiosis Agreements
+
** arms length
+
** long-term
+
** benefit both
+
** have a "market" basis e.g. use 30 day energy rates
+

Latest revision as of 17:49, 17 April 2012

Here are some notes (and follow on research) from our trip to Europe in April 2012.

Industrial Symbiosis

Kalundborg Symbiosis Center

Came from our 3 hour meeting with Mette Skovbjerg, Project Manager and Berndt Jespersen on Tuesday - April 10, 2012.

Basic Concepts

  • How it works
    • Waste of one company = Raw material for the next
    • Unit Transferred = Waste Fraction
    • Please note the "mindset is free!"
  • Agreements: ...each interconnect --- symbiotic relationship has:
    • an arms length commercial agreement
      • Agreements are typically 10 - 15 years
    • makes each company better
    • grew organically...no master plan, not a project, not an organization...it's a mindset
      • seems to have been started by bthe engineers working together
    • have a "market" basis e.g. use 30 day energy rates for heat transfer
  • Principles
    • 1) Members that fit together can (need) to be different
      • more difficult to combine waste streams of similar companies
    • 2) Focus on continuous waste streams
      • Some are combining waste streams for several "suppliers" to meet the need
    • 3) Each project is economically sustainable on it's own
      • Payback timeframes have moved from 3-5yrs to 1-2 yrs
    • 4) Physical location needs to be close by
    • 5) Mental distance between partners needs to be short
  • Value Pyramid (using $/lb)...make the highest use of the waste
    • 1) Medicine / Beauty ($/lb)
    • 2) Nutrient
    • 3) Animal Food
    • 4) Energy
    • unit prices go up dramatically
    • first... use output at highest value
  • Symbiosis evolution
    • 1.0 pure economics
    • 2.0 Green...clean future together
      • the power plant needs to be green by demand of the pharmacutical company
      • "Can we solve this future better together?" Can get more by working together


Symbionic Examples

  • Fish farming ... uses 9C water from the power plant
  • Pyroneer = gasifier
  • Gypno - gypsum company near a power plant


Other Symbiosis Resources

  • SymbioCity - Sweden's national vision and support for sustainable cities based on industrial symbiosis.
  • Plantagon
    • There is a company in Sweden that is selling greenhouses called Plantagon.
    • Very advanced approach.
    • Hans Hassle, the owner, is very advanced in his thinking.
    • They also have a philosophy for Industrial Symbiosis for urban agriculture.
  • NISP - National Industrial Symbiosis Program in the UK
    • They are trying to help get industrial symbiosis' formed....lots on their website
    • They have a website where you can post your waste you want to "sell"
    • They have a facilitation approach to find waste matches
  • Yale University Center for Industrial Ecology;


Other Sustainability Ideas

  • Wind Turbines ... Berndt's info
    • One windmill = 400 mWatts
    • People don't like the way they look
    • Pension funds are funding the projects
    • One of Bern's neighbors funded one.
    • How about Catalaunch and wind
    • Building on land is 1 fraction of cost of building at sea
    • by 2010 100% of Denmark's energy is to be renewable!
  • Algae innovators ecoduna
    • Out of Austria
    • Have production in Germany with a power company Vattenfall...project can be read about here.
  • Solum
    • Anaerobic Digestion company from Denmark
    • Aikan technology
    • Have compost and gas production together
    • This may be the answer to the water!!! It reuses the water over and over again. Cirulating it.
    • Very low tech...but very innovative in the design
  • Heat storage in vertical tanks
    • 125C at top and 50C at the bottom (presurized)
    • Use stratification to help.
    • put input heat in the top...put cold in the bottom
    • could mix if you need some temp in between
    • uses large collendar like filters at the top and bottom to take the input but prevent the mixing